Bot accounts being Basic

They haven’t communicated yet about that

Yes I love it this way. If the time of reviewing wasn’t too busy, then the time for voting too should not be too busy… expecting those who got time to review projects vote

You have to see it before the final results. How can we report issues on voting :joy:

It’s also nice to have all the teams trying to push until the last second. Well at least this time projects don’t spam other entries comment sections haha

1 Like

Let’s wait and see :slight_smile: you know I know you know :joy:

1 Like

Hahahahaha I am eager to confirm :joy::joy::joy:

1 Like

Many great suggestions have been giving over the years on this topic. In my opinion one of the best ways is to give options to connect or link our telegram and twitter accounts with our forum account. I would also like to give one more suggestion maybe many of you may not agree with it but I think it could be the best way to prevent fraud voters. Give us the option to link our Tron wallet address with our forum account. And only accounts who have staked 1000 or 100 TRX in the Tron network should be eligible to vote.

1 Like

Actually could have a soulbound nft offered on a DID platform made by trondao. They could give energy to the contract so people could mint for free.

Then with tronlink, sign a message on the forum and they could control that the wallet holds that nft.

It doesn’t prevent people from asking friends and family to mint that nft just to resell votes or pump their own project but it would limit it as nobody really wants to share their ID easily.

1 Like

Hey there, confirmed, Results will be public until Nov 13th :wink:

3 Likes

Great suggestions from you all but like @fabsltsa said linking our HTX account will definitely make users from the U.S ineligible to vote. There is this security infrastructure I have seen many platforms using which I think will be great if we can adapt to it. The infrastructure will ask new users to record their face and make 3 circles with their head. The purpose of this is to give a face to every account that will be created and ensure that a user doesn’t have more than 1 account. @SimbadMarino do you have any opinion on this?

1 Like

Did you mean “won’t” be public until Nov 13?
That will be 2 very long weeks :smiling_face_with_tear:

1 Like

On one hand I like to think about how to make the hackathon more safe, but on another hand, I think a lot of legit people won’t be willing to share biometrics data just to be able to vote.

For me the best choice is to split:

  • Judges prize: funds to help projects to keep building
  • Community prize: an invitation to join an accelerator that will help the project with co-marketing and networking

Marketing costs a lot of money to projects who really want to keep building. So it won’t change much for them. It will actually be even better cause marketing agencies cost an arm. For those who expected to get fast free money by tricking the community vote system, they won’t have anything to win since they didn’t intend to keep running the project.

@admin.hackathon @TronLive @SimbadMarino what’s your take on this?

1 Like

Since biometrics is not requesting for any personal information of the user, I don’t think a genuine person will find it difficult to do. And more, only the admins get to see the faces behind every account, the users can still use any pfp of their choice. So basically, there is no security concerns a user should be afraid of while making a biometrics.

Great discussion going on here! We are also observing a lot of basic account getting formed, and number of votes increasing very rapidly. While some are building their projects, some people might be busy building new accounts with basic to vote their projects. We think a very basic filter should be to not allow people to vote, who joined after the voting already began. They don’t have followed the projects closely, can be seen randomly pasting ai content on chats to gain basic, so it makes no sense to allow them to vote and decide the fate of projects. What are your thoughts?? @fabsltsa @leohymon @manfred_jr @maaz @Nweke-nature1.com @SimbadMarino and all other folks following this thread.

Already received some DMs from folks asking to buy votes for $$. Community voting is indeed a very tough things to tackle.

4 Likes

If you prevent new users to vote when the voting period started, fraudsters will just create profiles earlier for the next season. So it’s just a temporary fix. We need something more durable. I think that removing cash prize for community vote could be enough. And instead providing services like advertising on tronscan, ama with trondao, networking with HTX, Poloniex, vc,… for instance

3 Likes

If trondao has connections with marketing agencies, they could get cheaper marketing packages.
So instead of giving let’s say 5k to a winner, he could get the equivalent of 7 or 8k in marketing (KOL boost, press release,…).

3 Likes

Right, this definitely makes sense. Maybe in judges selected category the number of positions can be increased to 7-10 per track in that case.
But particularly for this season, atleast I am expecting that filtering the new users should def reduce the number of bot account who are voting. Since we are a new project, we didn’t have any idea about this voting process, nor we are trying to bypass it now. But definitely I am convinced that we won’t be able to win in community track, because of these bot accounts. Maximum number of voters don’t even go through any project just vote randomly in other tracks and vote for their specific project.

2 Likes

If you are worried about the bots be rest assured that admins will sweep them all out, bots vote doesn’t count

2 Likes

Best way of to expect nothing, if you can look for shock absorbers . Hahah. It gonna be like …

1 Like

Big bro, you suggestion always great, but for this one, for what I understand now perfect solution. Lols

But can be managed and get to adapt to changes each session

From this some limitations I see

  1. Most will not meet up( including the genuine ones)

  2. Multiple accounts too, since it only to link only Tron link wallets.
    But maybe a link to HTX can be better alternative sha

1 Like